Home
FacebookTwitterSearchMenu
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Features
  • Knowledge Library
  • Columns
  • Customs
  • Jobs
  • Directory
  • FX Rates
  • Categories
    • Categories
    • Africa
    • Air Freight
    • BEE
    • Border Beat
    • COVID-19
    • Crime
    • Customs
    • Domestic
    • Duty Calls
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy/Fuel
    • Events
    • Freight & Trading Weekly
    • Imports and Exports
    • Infrastructure
    • International
    • Logistics
    • Other
    • People
    • Road/Rail Freight
    • Sea Freight
    • Skills & Training
    • Social Development
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • Trade/Investment
    • Webinars
  • Contact us
    • Contact us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Send us news
    • Editorial Guidelines
Africa
Economy
Logistics
Other

Will ‘force majeure’ apply to those affected by civil unrest?

23 Jul 2021
0 Comments

Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-mail
  • Print

In light of the recent civil unrest and its impact on all modes of logistics operations, particularly in KwaZulu-Natal, the issue of contractual performance and force majeure has been brought into sharp focus.

“Contracting parties, on both sides of the bargain, will need to be alive to the potential issues involved,” warns the TT Club, which has provided a useful guide to enable supply chain stakeholders to navigate the legal principles involved.

The advice comes with a caveat however – it is not intended to be a definitive statement of the law and, in any specific case, the Club advises those affected to take their own legal advice and notify their usual claims contact in case of accidents which are likely to trigger cover with the TT Club or other insurer.

Following the destruction of storage facilities, warehousing, distribution centres and cold stores and the impact on the Port of Durban and road and rail networks, many businesses declared force majeure, says the insurer.

“South African law does not have a standalone principle of force majeure as such, but the Courts do recognise force majeure clauses where these are expressly incorporated into the relevant contract.

“To determine the effect and scope of such a clause, the Court will need to interpret the language used. Of course, any shortcomings in the language are likely to be read against the party seeking to rely upon the clause. Accordingly, whether seeking to rely upon a force majeure clause or, indeed, challenging a contractual counterparty's right to do so, parties will need to give very careful consideration to the precise language used.”

In situations where a contract is silent on force majeure" it may however still be possible for either party to seek to avoid performance of its contractual obligations, based upon the legal principle of "supervening impossibility of performance".

“In essence, this is very similar to force majeure and it refers to a situation where performance was possible at the time the contract was concluded, but subsequently became objectively and permanently impossible through no fault of the parties,” the insurer explains. “The impossibility must be beyond the control of the parties and must be caused by either vis major or casus fortuitous.”

While these are distinct legal concepts, there is no practical distinction between the two, the Club points out. “Vis major is akin to an 'act of God' or an irresistible force that includes events such as a natural catastrophe; casus fortuitous is a fortuitous or unavoidable accident, which no ordinary care or oversight could prevent, such as an act of the state, for example, new legislation or a declaration of war.

“One must always bear in mind that whether a party is excused performance of its contractual obligations depends on the precise circumstances of the particular case and the nature of the impossibility. The rule will not help a party if the impossibility is self-created or if the impossibility is due to his or her fault. Another key point is that the event must render performance absolutely or objectively impossible. Mere personal incapacity to perform, or where performance has simply been made uneconomical for a party, does not mean that performance has become impossible.”

The Club says there are clearly arguments in favour of the view that the civil unrest will fall within the ambit of casus fortuitous, making performance of a contract impossible. “That said, every case will need to be determined on its own facts and the onus of proving the impossibility will lie upon the party taking this position.”

 

 

 

 

Sign up to our mailing list and get daily news headlines and weekly features directly to your inbox free.
Subscribe to receive print copies of Freight News Features to your door.

Drivers targeted in latest cross-border scam at Kasumbalesa

Logistics
Road/Rail Freight

The Copperbelt’s most important border has been flagged for another scam aimed at fleecing truck drivers.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Automated multiple entries secure declaration ease on the TKC

Logistics
Road/Rail Freight
Technology

Removing single manifest entries is a major headache for consol cargo clients transiting through Botswana.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Global air cargo demand rises

Air Freight
Logistics

But some trade lanes have experienced a decline despite increased capacity.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Bank launches new SME exporter programme

Imports and Exports
Logistics

The development platform targets black-owned SMEs with turnovers under R50 million.

Yesterday
0 Comments

SA ports switch gear, record improved performance figures

Logistics

Latest data by the CMU heralded concurrent increases of 13% and 2% above target, said Saaff.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Unitrans scoops global safety award

Logistics

The company beat about 18 000 contractors in 35 countries to clinch the top accolade.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Logistics utility creates youth opportunities

Logistics
Skills & Training

The company has invested 6% of its total procurement spend in youth-owned business over the past year.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Transnet invites bids for liquid bulk terminal

Logistics
Sea Freight

The development will include storage tanks, road tanker loading gantries and pipelines.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Arrest of Molefe and others welcomed, but long-overdue – Saftu

Africa
Economy

The workers at UCW in Nigel – a local manufacturer with proven capacity – were the primary victims, Saftu said in a statement following the arrests.

30 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Sharp increase in box losses at sea

Logistics
Sea Freight

A recurrence of last year’s losses off the Cape of Good Hope has not yet been observed in 2025.

30 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Lack of rail interoperability stymies progress

Road/Rail Freight

“The AU has called for an integrated transport sector with world-class infrastructure that crisscrosses the continent." – Mesela Nhlapo, CEO, Aria.

30 Jun 2025
0 Comments

DRC-Rwandan peace accord bodes well for Lobito Corridor

Logistics

The DRC and Rwanda have lapsed into a recurring internecine struggle in the Lake Kivu area.

30 Jun 2025
0 Comments
  • More

FeatureClick to view

Road & Rail 27 June 2025

Border Beat

Forum tightens net against border corruption
25 Jun 2025
Police clamp down on cross-border crime
17 Jun 2025
Zim's anti-smuggling measures delay legitimate freight operations
06 Jun 2025
More

Poll

Has South Africa's ports turned the corner?

Featured Jobs

New

Customs Admin Clerk

Tiger Recruitment
Blouberg - CPT
01 Jul
New

Export Controller

Lee Botti & Associates
Durban
30 Jun
More Jobs
  • © Now Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Freight News RSS
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Send us news
  • Contact us