Home
FacebookSearchMenu
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Features
  • Knowledge Library
  • Columns
  • Customs
  • Jobs
  • Directory
  • FX Rates
  • Categories
    • Categories
    • Africa
    • Air Freight
    • BEE
    • Border Beat
    • COVID-19
    • Crime
    • Customs
    • Domestic
    • Duty Calls
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy/Fuel
    • Events
    • Freight & Trading Weekly
    • Imports and Exports
    • Infrastructure
    • International
    • Logistics
    • Other
    • People
    • Road/Rail Freight
    • Sea Freight
    • Skills & Training
    • Social Development
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • Trade/Investment
    • Webinars
  • Contact us
    • Contact us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Send us news
    • Editorial Guidelines
Africa
Air Freight
Other

SAA’s rescue winds up – where to next?

01 Apr 2021
0 Comments

Share

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-mail
  • Print

As SAA’s business rescue process winds to a close, many South Africans, from aviation professionals to consumers, are questioning why the government is continuing to throw billions more taxpayers’ rands at the beleaguered entity.

Defending their actions, SAA’s business rescue practitioners (BRPs) have summed up the achievements that have been made in the last year.

“The primary achievement of the business rescue process was to transition SAA from an insolvent company to a company that is both solvent and liquid. To this end, the liabilities of the airline have been reduced by R35.7bn as a result of the compromises that have been negotiated by the BRPs with concurrent creditors and lessors,” said an SAA media statement.

The communication says that the BRPs’ negotiations have reduced SAA’s concurrent creditor liability by R7.4bn from R8bn to R600m. Its lessor liabilities have been reduced by R28.3bn from R30bn to R1.7bn. This amounts to a R35.7bn reduction in debt, says SAA.

SAA’s workforce has also been reduced from 4 700 to approximately 1 000 employees by means of Section 189 retrenchment processes and the provision of voluntary severance packages. The BRPs say they have also reduced the airline’s general overheads through renegotiation of supplier contracts, that they have managed to preserve the airline’s infrastructure and assets, and that the airline’s critical memberships, such as its Iata and Star Alliance memberships, remain in place.

But not everyone agrees with the validity of all the points made in the statement. Independent BRP and aviation economist, Dr Joachim Vermooten, disagrees with the BRPs’ summation. He says the business rescue goals have not been met and that SAA is not solvent, liquid or even operational.

“Just because the payment of its creditors has been deferred does not mean that SAA’s debt no longer exists or that the airline is solvent,” he says, adding that SAA is continuing to struggle with liquidity and cash-flow issues relating to payment of basic items such as staff salaries.

“Even when SAA has been in possession of funds to pay these items, they have had issues enacting payments, due to the DPE’s prescription on how it wants the funds to be utilised (outside the scope of the approved business rescue plan).  Furthermore, the BRPs have not been able to issue any financial statements that demonstrate that the airline has been returned to either liquidity or solvency,” says Vermooten.

Airlink is a creditor of SAA. Airlink MD and CEO, Rodger Foster, says SAA owes Airlink R535m plus a large sum relating to unflown ticket liability. “We were never in agreement with the SAA business rescue plan which, we felt, left out items essential for the turnaround and success of the airline.” He says while Airlink had voted against the proposed business rescue plan, its vote had counted very little because the amount owed, while a fortune to Airlink, was dwarfed in comparison to the sums owed to the banks.

The terms offered by the BRPs to creditors such as Airlink will see creditors recuperate only 7.5c in every rand owed to them by SAA. This means that Airlink will recuperate only R40.125m of the R535m owed.

“We are not happy with the outcome of the business rescue process and feel hard done by it, but we are doing our best to move on and run our business successfully,” says Foster, adding that the BRPs are sweeping a long list of SAA conflicts and litigious issues under the carpet, declaring a successful business rescue when the reality is that these issues have not gone away.

Vermooten told Travel News he believed business rescue processes should treat creditors equally rather than creating provision for offering full recovery of funds to unflown ticket holders but only 7.5c to every rand to other creditors. He also pointed out that employees owed money by SAA had received entirely different terms.

“Squeezing creditors that SAA hopes to retain relationships with when it restarts (such as aircraft lessors) is short-sighted and will result in suppliers offering SAA less generous terms going forward,” he adds.

Lastly, there is the question of the receivership. In order to exit business rescue, the BRPs must file a notice of substantial implementation as soon as all outstanding items have been addressed. The BRPs said, in a recent notification, that they were making every effort to finalise these outstanding items by the end of March:

  • Payment to employees, as a minimum the unpaid salaries or a provision for such payment.
  • Payment of the post-commencement creditors
  • The election by creditors of receivers, and the establishment of the receivership to enact the remaining creditor payments.

The business rescue plan outlines that the receiver’s job will be to receive the restructure proceeds and distribute these.

According to Vermooten, a successful business rescue process usually ends with the BRPs handing the company, in a solvent and liquid state, back to the company’s board of directors. He says it is unusual for a receivership to be appointed when the business rescue process ends.

MBA, LBA and finance specialist, Brett Evans, says the appointment of a Receiver is not a standard move for an entity in business rescue, but concedes that there could be some merit in the process, considering that the majority of the BRPs’ actions have already been completed and that the remaining creditor payments are expected to stretch out over the next few years.

Spokesperson for SAA’s BRPs, Louise Brugman, says while the appointment of a receiver is not the norm in business rescue proceedings, she understands that this route has been taken because of the complicated debt repayments that still need to take place, the payment of which will take years to conclude. “The receiver does not play an operational role in SAA other than to verify that creditors’ funds are valid before disbursing them,” explains Brugman.

  • Travel News
Sign up to our mailing list and get daily news headlines and weekly features directly to your inbox free.
Subscribe to receive print copies of Freight News Features to your door.

SA in bid to ban port worker strikes

Logistics

The Department of Labour has issued a directive to classify port and border employees as essential services.

2 hours ago
0 Comments

South African vehicle exports surge 7.9%

Imports and Exports

The automotive sector continues to play a vital role in the country’s manufacturing economy.

Today 12:45
0 Comments

Minerals Council rejects chrome export tax

Imports and Exports

The industry body warns that the duty will negatively affect chrome producers and jobs.

Today 12:00
0 Comments

Comprehensive steel duties gazetted

Imports and Exports

Goods originating in or imported from numerous developing countries are excluded.

Today 11:45
0 Comments

New regulation delays exports going to Lesotho

Logistics

RSL has said non-compliance is the primary reason for hold-ups at its ports of entry.

Today 11:45
0 Comments

New oil SOE secures 90% stake in Sudanese prospecting block

Energy/Fuel
Logistics

The block apparently contains reserves of up to 3.5 billion barrels of oil.

Today 11:45
0 Comments

Mining industry has bright future – Mantashe

Domestic
Economy
Trade/Investment

The minister believes it is a sunrise sector filled with new mineral opportunities for investors and the economy.

Today 09:30
0 Comments

Deployment of new RTGs at PoCT speeded up

Logistics

A general cargo vessel carrying a second batch of new RTGs is expected imminently.

Yesterday
0 Comments

ULCV successfully docks at Ngqura, makes history

Logistics
Sea Freight

“This achievement solidifies our status as a significant player in the maritime industry.” – TNPA

Yesterday
0 Comments

Trump tariffs – July 9 deadline draws nearer

Imports and Exports
Trade/Investment

One of the countries that has already learned its fate in the face of punishing duties is Vietnam.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Fuel price hikes a strain for consumers

Energy/Fuel

Double-digit price increases and a higher fuel levy will place financial pressure on households.

Yesterday
0 Comments

Pork for citrus? South Africa faces tough US trade choice

Imports and Exports

If SA’s disease-free status is compromised, PRRS could come at a heavy cost to local pork producers.

Yesterday
0 Comments
  • More

FeatureClick to view

Cold Chain Logistics 4 July 2025

Border Beat

Forum tightens net against border corruption
25 Jun 2025
Police clamp down on cross-border crime
17 Jun 2025
Zim's anti-smuggling measures delay legitimate freight operations
06 Jun 2025
More

Poll

Has South Africa's ports turned the corner?

Featured Jobs

Business Development Executive

Switch Recruit
Eastrand
02 Jul

Road Logistics Pricing Specialist

Tiger Recruitment
East Rand
02 Jul

Operations Manager

Lee Botti & Associates
Cape Town
02 Jul
More Jobs
  • © Now Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Freight News RSS
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Send us news
  • Contact us