Home
FacebookTwitterSearchMenu
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Features
  • Knowledge Library
  • Columns
  • Customs
  • Jobs
  • Directory
  • FX Rates
  • Categories
    • Categories
    • Africa
    • Air Freight
    • BEE
    • Border Beat
    • COVID-19
    • Crime
    • Customs
    • Domestic
    • Duty Calls
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy/Fuel
    • Events
    • Freight & Trading Weekly
    • Imports and Exports
    • Infrastructure
    • International
    • Logistics
    • Other
    • People
    • Road/Rail Freight
    • Sea Freight
    • Skills & Training
    • Social Development
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • Trade/Investment
    • Webinars
  • Contact us
    • Contact us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Send us news
    • Editorial Guidelines
Domestic
Other
Sea Freight

Outa wins court battle against Nersa and Karpowership

10 Jun 2024 - by Staff reporter
 Source: Business Recorder
0 Comments

Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-mail
  • Print

The Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa) has won a court challenge against Karpowership and the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) giving the civil rights organisation access to the unredacted record of the regulator’s decision to approve licences for the power vessels.

The Pretoria High Court was supposed to hear Outa’s application to compel the National Energy Regulator (Nersa) to provide it with the full, unredacted record of Nersa’s decisions to approve generation licences for Karpowership but the company recently withdrew its opposition and Nersa offered to settle minutes before the trial was supposed to start. 

This comes after Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy, Gwede Mantashe, in February 2020 made a determination that 2 000 MW of emergency generation capacity should be procured. Three Turkish Karpowership projects were given the green light to provide 1 220 MW of gas-fired generation capacity to the country over a 20-year period.

Outa opposed the cost, environmental impact and length of the controversial contract, and filed a court application for Nersa’s decision to grant Karpowership independent power producer (IPP) licences to be reviewed and set aside. Nersa and Karpowership opposed the application.

“Outa strongly believes that Nersa’s decision should be reviewed and set aside as it was procedurally unfair, premature and lacking in transparency. Outa, in the main application (the review application), called for Nersa to provide copies of all documents relating to the decisions to grant Karpowership the generation licences, together with the reasons for the decisions,” said Stefanie Fick, Outa’s accountability division executive director.

Nersa provided only a redacted version of the record in June 2022, and Outa then asked the court to compel Nersa to produce the full, unredacted record of its decision. The application was set down for hearing on June 4 and 5. 

However, just before the hearing, Nersa’s attorneys presented a settlement agreement in which it agreed to provide the full unredacted record, subject to a confidentiality regime.

Outa partially accepted the settlement agreement, reserving its right to argue at the review hearing that the provided record, which Nersa and Karpowership believe to be confidential, should be made publicly available. Nersa accepted this and the court handed down a consent order.

On the issue of costs, Outa asked the court to award a punitive cost order against both Nersa and Karpowership due to their conduct in the matter.

During court arguments it emerged that Nersa was only willing to settle because Karpowership had permitted it to conclude confidentiality agreements.

“It is despicable to think that Nersa, our independent national energy regulator, will keep information away from public scrutiny unless it is given permission to do so by third parties. Transparency is crucial for accountability, and when parties want to do business with government they should accept that their conduct will be under a microscope,” Fick said. 

The court ruled that Nersa and Karpowership pay the cost of the application on a punitive scale, including the cost of Outa’s counsel.

The main application for a review of Nersa’s decision to grant the Karpowership licences continues.

Sign up to our mailing list and get daily news headlines and weekly features directly to your inbox free.
Subscribe to receive print copies of Freight News Features to your door.

Contentious MSB clause up for discussion at EWC presentation

Logistics

Cargo owners and their agents will most likely want to make use of multimodal alternatives.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Surging prices lift food inflation to 4.4% y-o-y in May

Economy
Social Development

Headline consumer inflation remained well contained after a surprising pause at 2.8% y-o-y in May.

 

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Houthi threat to Israeli-linked shipping remains high

Sea Freight

States that launch military action against the Houthis or Iran could also face danger in the region.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Airlink expands fleet to grow routes in Africa

Africa
Air Freight

Ten aircraft will be leased from Azorra, boosting capacity and cutting fuel use by 29%.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

MDM imports – poultry pips pilchards to the post

Imports and Exports

Mechanically deboned meat is essential in producing affordable processed protein products.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Has Botswana lost its sparkle? (No, think copper!)

Africa
Freight & Trading Weekly
Trade/Investment

The falling market and sliding prices have already taken a toll, with GDP contracting by 3% in the last financial year.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Second round of SA-US trade talks: what lies ahead in Luanda?

Economy
Imports and Exports
Trade/Investment

For the time being, South Africa is exempt from the aluminium tariff, but for how long?

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

SA airports get massive infrastructure revamp

Air Freight
Infrastructure

Fuel reliability at OR Tambo International Airport will be improved with a new 20-inch jet fuel line and redundancy system.

20 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Freight futures react as Iran-Israel conflict spirals

Logistics

Before last Friday’s surprise attack, VLCC rates were stable at about $20 000 per day.

19 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Trans-Kalahari Corridor congestion at record levels

Logistics
Road/Rail Freight

Previously, Botswana would allow consolidated cargo to be cleared as a single consignment.

19 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Meat importers welcome partial lifting of poultry ban

Imports and Exports

But say the government must accelerate the reopening of other key poultry import markets in Europe.

19 Jun 2025
0 Comments

Views differ about improved port performance

Logistics

Into June, the combined average for all terminals heralded a compliance rating of 80%.

19 Jun 2025
0 Comments
  • More

FeatureClick to view

Botswana 20 June 2025

Border Beat

Police clamp down on cross-border crime
17 Jun 2025
Zim's anti-smuggling measures delay legitimate freight operations
06 Jun 2025
Cross-border payments remain a hurdle – Masondo
30 May 2025
More

Poll

Has South Africa's ports turned the corner?

Featured Jobs

Senior Sea/Air Import/Export Controller (Multimodal Controller) Strong on Imports

Tiger Recruitment
East Rand
20 Jun
More Jobs
  • © Now Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Freight News RSS
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Send us news
  • Contact us