Performance-based pilot cuts truck crash rates by 70%

The Council for Scientific and

Industrial Research (CSIR)

is in the process of finalising

an evaluation report on its

Performance Based Standards

(PBS) pilot project.

According to Dr Paul

Nordengen, the project, a

subset of the Road Traffic

Management System, has been

extremely successful. It has

resulted in a 70% reduction

in crash rates and a weighted

average 28.5% reduction

in heavy vehicle trips to

transport the same freight – in

addition to a 20% reduction

in fuel consumption and a

significantly increased payload

efficiency.

“In June we will reach 100

million km on this pilot project

which was first launched

in 2007 under the banner

of Smart Trucks,” he said

at the annual Road Freight

Association (RFA) conference.

“By the end of this year, through

this pilot project 365 000 trips,

42.3 million km, 11 million

litres of fuel and 29 000 tons of

CO2 will have been saved.”

With more than 168 vehicles

on the pilot (South Africa has

more than 230 official smart

trucks), he said they were now

in the process of drawing up the

evaluation report to present to

the Department of Transport

for decision making on how to

proceed into the future.

With not all provinces on

board with the programme,

Nordengen said it was

imperative to increase

provincial participation while

research continued.

“We are also developing

a smart truck portal

administration system for

monitoring and evaluation,”

he said.

It remains uncertain what

government will do with

the findings of this highly

successful research pilot

programme, but it is hopeful

that legislation will be updated

to accommodate the longer and

heavier vehicles that operate on

the programme.

“The national department

of transport

is actively

engaged

with the

project,” said

Nordengen.

“We are in

the process

of preparing

the report

which will be

presented to

government

and then we

will be able to

decide on the way forward.”

He said at present RTMS

certification was a prerequisite

to be on the PBS programme,

something not all operators

were happy about but it was

essential to have a minimum

standard in place and RTMS

assured that. The RTMS is

a voluntary self-regulation

scheme that tries to encourage

consignees, consignors and

road transport operators to

implement a management

system to contribute to

preserving road infrastructure,

improving road safety and

increasing productivity

He said while PBS was not a

silver bullet it had made some

significant findings.

“We have seen fewer vehicle

breakdowns, fewer driver error

crashes and improved driver

behaviour, while speeding

incidents have gone down from

299 per year per truck to 18.

There’s an estimated annual

saving of R115 million per year

thanks to the reduced crash

rate alone.”

The project,

which started

with only

two vehicles

in 2007, has

continued to

gain traction,

showcasing

what can

be achieved

with a

performancebased

approach

– even when

using heavier and longer

vehicles.

“Most countries control

heavy vehicle use on the road

network through prescriptive

regulations, which do not

seem effective in many cases,

particularly in developing

countries. PBS uses a different

approach, specifying the

performance required from the

operation of a vehicle on a road

network, thus what a vehicle

can do,” explains Nordengen.

There’s an estimated

annual saving of

R115 million per year

thanks to the reduced

crash rate alone.

– Dr Paul Nordengen