Home
FacebookSearchMenu
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Features
  • Knowledge Library
  • Columns
  • Customs
  • Jobs
  • Directory
  • FX Rates
  • Categories
    • Categories
    • Africa
    • Air Freight
    • BEE
    • Border Beat
    • COVID-19
    • Crime
    • Customs
    • Domestic
    • Duty Calls
    • Economy
    • Employment
    • Energy/Fuel
    • Events
    • Freight & Trading Weekly
    • Imports and Exports
    • Infrastructure
    • International
    • Logistics
    • Other
    • People
    • Road/Rail Freight
    • Sea Freight
    • Skills & Training
    • Social Development
    • Sustainability
    • Technology
    • Trade/Investment
    • Webinars
  • Contact us
    • Contact us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Send us news
    • Editorial Guidelines
Africa
Domestic
Road/Rail Freight

Industry welcomes Aarto victory

13 Jan 2022 - by Lyse Comins
 Source: ENCA
0 Comments

Share

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-mail
  • Print

The Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Act (Aarto) was both ‘unconstitutional and invalid’ the Pretoria High Court ruled on Thursday.

It ruled that both the Aarto Act and the Aarto Amendment Act were unconstitutional and ordered the first and third respondents, the minister of transport and the Road Traffic Infringement Agency (RTIA), to pay the legal costs of the applicant, the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa).

Outa had challenged the constitutional validity of Aarto and the Aarto Amendment Act, and asked the court in October 2021 to declare both the main act and the amendment act unconstitutional. 

Judge Annali Basson agreed with Outa’s position that the legislation unlawfully intruded upon the exclusive executive and legislative competence of the local and provincial governments envisaged in the Constitution, preventing local and provincial governments from regulating their own affairs. 

The respondents in the case were the minister of transport, the minister of cooperative governance and traditional affairs, RTIA, and the Appeals Tribunal. 

Outa has raised its concerns and objections about the Aarto Act and the published Aarto Amendment Act for a number of years, and shared its concerns with relevant authorities before the Amendment Act was published.  The organisation said it believed that these pieces of traffic legislation were unconstitutional and would also not assist with curbing road traffic fatalities in South Africa. 

Judge Basson concluded in her judgment: “It therefore follows in my view that the Aarto Act and the Amendment Act must be declared to be inconsistent with the Constitution in its entirety. It is therefore declared that the Aarto Act and the Amendment Acts are unconstitutional and invalid.”

Advocate Stefanie Fick, executive director of the accountability and governance divisions at Outa, said the organisation was “very pleased” with the court’s decision.

“Outa believes that Aarto in its current format does nothing to improve road safety, nor does it reduce the scourge of road fatalities in South Africa. We are satisfied that the judgment will be sending government back to the drawing board. This time around, we trust the relevant departments will engage meaningfully with civil society to obtain our input when developing such important policies for the country,” Fick said.

She added that the judgment signalled another important win for civil society, which indicated that the government was out of touch with reality. 

“It is unfortunate that government once again chose to ignore valid concerns and well-researched input, and pushed ahead with the amendment. Not only did they waste a lot of time, but also valid resources, as the Aarto roll-out will have to be stopped while the act is once again amended and taken through the legislative process. Only then can it be implemented,” Fick said.

However, the battle to protect motorists from the ill-conceived act was not yet over, she added. 

“Outa urges government to listen to the input given by organisations such as Outa when reviewing these acts.  We can assure the public that we will carefully monitor the process to ensure that any revised Aarto acts are constitutional and truly aimed at increased road safety and saving lives.”   

Road Freight Association CEO Gavin Kelly said the organisation had not yet examined the full judgment but it was “interesting” that the court had found the initial Aarto Act (Act 46 of 1998) unconstitutional.

“The Bill (before it became the Aarto Act 46 of 1998) passed Constitutional scrutiny then. The fact that the High Court finds the Aarto Amendment Act (Act 4 of 2019) as unconstitutional is not surprising as there were many major changes made to the original Act,” he said.

“The RFA supports road safety, the role that traffic policing must play in increasing safety, and compliance with the various legislative requirements to support safer roads for all users. The RFA has been very clear and outspoken about the flaws that the association identified in Aarto that - in our view - was predicated on revenue generation and not on changing driver behaviour and vehicle maintenance to ensure safer roads,” Kelly said.

“We trust that the minister of transport will consider more effective, targeted and sustainable implementable solutions to reduce road traffic crashes.”

He said that over the 2020/2021 festive season the number and severity of road crashes had been dramatically reduced without Aarto being in place.

“The use of resources to specifically target known causes proved that a complicated system of demerit points, administration of drivers and vehicles regarding point thresholds, and the payment of levies and penalties to facilitate ‘swifter administration’ of traffic law obedience is not necessary,” Kelly said.

He said the RFA supported the non-implementation of a system that would have created administrative labour and cost nightmares for all South African drivers - and more so any company that operated a fleet.

Sign up to our mailing list and get daily news headlines and weekly features directly to your inbox free.
Subscribe to receive print copies of Freight News Features to your door.

Port of Ngqura to welcome first ultra large container vessel

Logistics
Sea Freight

The ULCV stands nearly three metres taller than vessels typically handled at the terminal.

02 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Global ferry body strikes deal to boost safety

Logistics
Sea Freight

The agreement promotes cooperation between international members and operators in West and Central Africa.

02 Jul 2025
0 Comments

SITA appoints Pedro Alves as senior vice president

Air Freight
Technology

The new VP is taking the reins at a time when the needs of border agencies are fast evolving.

02 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Drivers targeted in latest cross-border scam at Kasumbalesa

Logistics
Road/Rail Freight

The Copperbelt’s most important border has been flagged for another scam aimed at fleecing truck drivers.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Automated multiple entries secure declaration ease on the TKC

Logistics
Road/Rail Freight
Technology

Removing single manifest entries is a major headache for consol cargo clients transiting through Botswana.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Global air cargo demand rises

Air Freight
Logistics

But some trade lanes have experienced a decline despite increased capacity.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Bank launches new SME exporter programme

Imports and Exports
Logistics

The development platform targets black-owned SMEs with turnovers under R50 million.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

SA ports switch gear, record improved performance figures

Logistics

Latest data by the CMU heralded concurrent increases of 13% and 2% above target, said Saaff.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Unitrans scoops global safety award

Logistics

The company beat about 18 000 contractors in 35 countries to clinch the top accolade.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Logistics utility creates youth opportunities

Logistics
Skills & Training

The company has invested 6% of its total procurement spend in youth-owned business over the past year.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Transnet invites bids for liquid bulk terminal

Logistics
Sea Freight

The development will include storage tanks, road tanker loading gantries and pipelines.

01 Jul 2025
0 Comments

Arrest of Molefe and others welcomed, but long-overdue – Saftu

Africa
Economy

The workers at UCW in Nigel – a local manufacturer with proven capacity – were the primary victims, Saftu said in a statement following the arrests.

30 Jun 2025
0 Comments
  • More

FeatureClick to view

Cold Chain Logistics 4 July 2025

Border Beat

Forum tightens net against border corruption
25 Jun 2025
Police clamp down on cross-border crime
17 Jun 2025
Zim's anti-smuggling measures delay legitimate freight operations
06 Jun 2025
More

Poll

Has South Africa's ports turned the corner?

Featured Jobs

New

Road Logistics Pricing Specialist

Tiger Recruitment
East Rand
02 Jul
New

Operations Manager

Lee Botti & Associates
Cape Town
02 Jul
More Jobs
  • © Now Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Freight News RSS
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Send us news
  • Contact us