Find government COVID 19 information at https://sacoronavirus.co.za
Home
FacebookTwitterSearchMenu
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • Features
  • Knowledge Library
  • Columns
  • Customs
  • Jobs
  • Directory
  • FX Rates
  • Contact us
    • Contact us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Send us news

Knowledge Library

Arresting a ship under business rescue – some clarity from the court

Publish Date: 
15 Jan 2019

Ship arrests, under section 10 of the Admiralty Jurisdiction Regulation Act 1 (AJRA), and business rescue, under section 133 of the Companies Act (the Companies Act), have finally received clarity from our courts.

In the case of Southern African Shipyards (Pty) Ltd v MFV "Polaris" and Others [2018] 3 All SA 219 (WCC), the applicant sought leave to sell the MFV Polaris, a motor fishing vessel, her equipment, furniture, bunkers and cargo in terms of section 9 of AJRA, to pay for repairs it had made to the vessel in February 2016.

On 1 June 2017, the applicant and the ship’s agents entered into an acknowledgement of debt. The agents agreed to pay 50% of the outstanding debt of R2 142 151.15 within seven days. 

The applicant arrested the vessel after the agent failed to pay.

The respondent opposed the arrest, arguing that section 10 of AJRA conflicted with sections 128 to 155 and 133 of the Companies Act that cause a temporary stay on proceedings against a company in business rescue. Section 10 of AJRA excludes property arrested for a maritime claim or security (given in respect of such property or the proceeds of any property sold in execution), from property vested in and administered by a trustee, insolvency liquidator or judicial manager.  It also prohibits temporary stay in proceedings of property through sequestration, winding up or judicial management.

The agent argued that the Companies Act should prevail over AJRA and that the vessel could not be sold as it was under the control of the business rescue practitioners.

The applicant denied that section 133 of the Companies Act applied to the sale proceedings and argued that the temporary stay proceedings should not result in the vessel’s release.

The court found that the purpose of section 10 of AJRA was to exclude maritime property that was under arrest from the control of a trustee in a sequestration or under administration of a liquidator in a winding up or a judicial manager.  It also held that the language of section 10 limited its application to an arrest of maritime property before the commencement of the debtor’s winding up and was applicable to business rescue proceedings.

The court granted the order for the sale of the vessel and found that the section should be interpreted to apply to business rescue proceedings. 

This means that once a company is in business rescue, its property vests in the business rescue practitioners and cannot be arrested after the business rescue process commences.  However, if the arrest occurs before that point, the property does not fall under the control of the business rescue practitioners.

While it seems that the court has resolved the apparent conflict between AJRA and the Companies Act, it will be worthwhile for the legislature to amend section 10 of AJRA by specifically making reference to business rescue proceedings in order to avoid uncertainty.

By Abongile Swana, Associate, Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa

Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • E-mail
  • Print

Articles

Freight transport companies need to do due diligence

Logistics
09 Jan 2020
0 Comments

How to avoid cyber crime

Technology
27 Nov 2019
0 Comments

How new Aarto bill will affect insurance premiums

Economy
26 Aug 2019
0 Comments

What the energy industry looks for in fuel transporters

Logistics
26 Jul 2019
0 Comments

Carbon tax: legal assessment guide for companies

Domestic
18 Jun 2019
0 Comments

Carriers beware: clarifying the onus in cargo damage claims

Sea Freight
13 Jun 2019
0 Comments

Carbon Tax Bill to cut emissions in South Africa from June 1

Economy
22 May 2019
0 Comments

A roadmap to European success

International
09 May 2019
0 Comments

Banking fraud – tips on how to avoid becoming a victim

Technology
02 May 2019
0 Comments

The African Continental Free Trade Area - facilitating dispute resolution in Africa

Domestic
13 Mar 2019
0 Comments

Supreme Court of Appeal protects shipowners’ property rights

Sea Freight
15 Feb 2019
0 Comments

Supreme Court of Appeal protects shipowners’ property rights

Sea Freight
15 Feb 2019
0 Comments

Learn how to get ready for ocean freight rate negotiations

Sea Freight
11 Dec 2018
0 Comments

A quick guide to make picking & packaging more efficient

Imports and Exports
27 Nov 2018
0 Comments

Tips to ensure against truck accidents

Road/Rail Freight
13 Nov 2018
0 Comments

Disadvantages of Trade Finance and how to avoid them

Imports and Exports
30 Oct 2018
0 Comments

E-Commerce and TMS: The role of transportation technology for shippers to kill it at e-commerce

Technology
23 Oct 2018
0 Comments

Why big data in shipping and freight is important

Sea Freight
02 Oct 2018
0 Comments

Does rand depreciation help South Africa’s exports?

Imports and Exports
19 Sep 2018
0 Comments

Could your goods be quarantined?

Imports and Exports
04 Sep 2018
0 Comments
  • More

Filter by Topic

Domestic
Economy
Imports and Exports
International
Logistics
People
Road/Rail Freight
Sea Freight
Technology
  • © Now Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Freight News RSS
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Send us news
  • Contact us